Synergising our Security
July 8, 2012 by Team SAISA
Filed under internal security
First response in an integrated intelligence environment is crucial to protect mega cities.
Hyderabad, 28 June 2012, terrorists struck at Gachibawli stadium, Charminar and Inox at 1.30 pm; firing indiscriminately.
Before they could kill/injure more than 3 people at Gachibawli, the local self-protection group and the citizen forum swung into action. The local policemen on duty fixed these two suicide operators and forced them to take cover. The sports authority managers and volunteers moved the players and the crowd to safety.
Simultaneously, through a simple pre loaded SMS the twitter went across control rooms of all police stations, the 108 and all quick reaction teams as also ambulances were directed towards the stadium. A similar exercise was put into action for Charminar and the Inox.
By 1.35 PM, while a pitched battle between the police and terrorists was on, the quick reaction teams of rapid action and police reached various venues. After a swift 30 minute battle, the terrorists at all the three places were killed. In the meantime, the entire city had gone into over drive with army, NSG and CRPF reaction teams moving into key localities business centres and installations including bus/train stations and airport.
The cities crowd and traffic management volunteers had diverted traffic and people away from the attack venues and ambulances reached the sites to ferry injured to the nearest hospitals.
All this in these golden 30 minutes between 1.30 and 2 PM. By 2.15 PM a joint statement by the state and city leaders was made on news channels calming nerves of the entire nation and the world.
Possible ! Yes. That is one way effects of terror or suicide attacks can be minimized and situation brought under control – If the preparations for the first 30 golden minutes are put in place.
The exercise is based on few premises. A holistic approach to city security by the local administration, an integrated system of operation employing ICT (Information Communication Technologies) with real-time connectivity to all architectures and nodes in question, (Police, army, CRPF, hospitals, corporate). It needs a dedicated response mechanism between various agencies involved and public information and empowerment systems.
A basic module of the architecture was put in place by Hyderabad administration by through a private public partnership when “Satyam” and the Naidu Government took the first step towards synergizing the response mechanism in 2003. As a result 108 service was born. A lot of volunteers worked on the project and with in a year the service with the aim of integrating hospitals, PCRs and reaction vehicles was organized to ensure casualty management in the city in the event of an accident to save lives. Its scope though limited, was a tedious process warranting digitization of local maps, satellite overlays database management, people, police, hospital, ambulances interconnecting these, and training and educating various components participating in the venture.
It should now be taken to its logical next step which would follow the “Golden 30 Minutes” principle in which the city would be ready to meet any contingency, limit the damage, ensure safety of citizens and installations and above all act as a deterrent to any misadventure. A refined systems approach towards crisis management entails few basic processes.
Firstly, a dedicated and vibrant intelligence mechanism by the District administration involving various agencies on a real-time basis is an absolute must. Regular updates, meetings, red teaming are part of the growth mechanism of this setup. An active citizen’s response and warning update system also needs to be put in place to verify all inputs and strengthen intelligence.
Secondly, An architecture based on latest communication and IT techniques to link the entire mechanism real-time.
Thirdly, Resources of police, CRPF, Army, hospitals, ambulances, civil volunteer groups, corporate security organizations need to be integrated and harmonised in a sectored approach towards generating the desired responses.
Fourth and most important – the key to stabilising and preventing immediate damage is the first response – the police, CRPF or other security organisations on duty. It is these one-two men team who need to be trained, geared and motivated to take on the first response and fix the terrorists while the entire system swings into action.
Lastly, this entire arrangement works on the basis of active citizen participation. Hence public awareness, motivation and civil defence education at various levels is an absolute must.
An arrangement of this nature must start from grass root levels. If the districts and city centres can be energized, the upward multi channel linking and synergy towards state and national level will be that much faster.
It is when efforts at district and National levels approach the problem from both ends an enduring answer would follow.
This piece is a replay of a 2010 piece brought out again in line with Nitin Gokhale’s incisive article on protecting our mega cities. Nothing great seems to have changed including stalling of an effective National Counter Terrorism Centre.


A promising example of a efficient tactical level anti-terror response at a time when most of our responses at micro and macro levels are pathetic. Several points are posted for consideration:
1. Choose the right leader for anti-terror response. Having an IPS officer head a largely Army force such as in the NSG needs reconsideration.It is as absurd as having an Army General head a police force in a terror affected state. He will fail as you need grass roots understanding and shared experiences to succeed in anti terror operations.
2. False alarms will create mayhem and it is a terror tactic to do just that. SMS led deployment needs a careful over watch to avoid the spread of cynicism amongst respondents.
3. Common frequencies for various respondents and common equipment as also coded capability is needed. Communication/frequency management and its security is a must. So are rehearsals; not for the cameras but to develop mutual trust and respect.
Couldn’t agree more. E security forms an inherent part along with red teaming to build the beat constable’s capabilities – a must for this model to work.
Terror attacks have come to stay in our country,and we need to learn to live with it.The question is,how do we limit the damages,and how fast we isolate the terror stricken area.Big cities and installations are reasonably adequately protected.We now need to spread this cover to other areas.There is a great deal of mistrust between the Centre and the States with regards to the NCTC.May be the States will have to evolve plans and create an organisation to swiftly deal with such situations,while the National assets will suppliment the efforts and action taken by the States.Based on the experiences we have had so far,we need to evolve an organisation and modus-operandi,and give it to the States to operationalise it.Brigadier(Retd)PK Sanyal.